Since a collaboration government has cores on its territory, the puppet master will not need to garrison the territory and resistance will not form. so playing as germany, should I not worry about it for countries like poland? 1. If you are, you are unable to use this option. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. You are using an out of date browser. I am not sure what you mean by redoing collaboration governments. For larger countries it might be optimal to occupy everything except their capital tile so they don't capitulate. In another thread, someone suggested that collaboration governments, being as expensive as they are, only lend themselves to being formed in France. Fll collabo government gives 75% CIC and 75% MIC, plus manpower and expeditionary forces to Overlord. They only cost certain amounts of civilian factories for anywhere between 20 days and 3 months, and once you have 3 you will be able to form a collaboration government as soon as you occupy all the enemy land (which should be easier as they capitulate quicker due to lower surrender limit). JavaScript is disabled. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. But basically, the collaboration government is a new country that's your puppet, and "collaboration government" is a lower level of puppet than anything else including integrated puppet and reichskommisariat. I saw somewhere you dont get all the factories or resources but its easier to manage. Really quickly, before we begin, you cannot be Democratic. Forming an actual collaboration government you only do once. The collaboration government has the technology of the current overruling government. The collaboration government mission can give a country up to 100% compliance which gives the country occupying the country with the set up collabs 99% of the countries resources and factories. If you're going to war with a non-core country and annex them you'll want this. It gives huge benefits, its by far the easiest way to raise compliance, and its honestly not a huge expenditure of resources. Reposting from another thread on collaboration since this thread has more people posting: It's honestly really confusing. Sons of the Forest: What to do at the Grave? Reduces surrender limit, speeding up the process of ending wars. Collaboration governments are special puppets with very very limited autonomy, lower than an integrated puppet, that share the same color as your country and get a name such as "German Russia" or "American France". Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Collaboration is necessary for curbing and eliminating resistance. Having to micromanage your government can be fantastic and brutal, all at the same time. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. I can see number of units with and without decyphering. I was comparing the Netherlands and France both of whom surrendered within a week of each other. Fun Fact: Major Josef Gangl is a generic General Portrait in Hoi4. Nerds and Scoundrels is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Wizards of the Coast Fan Content Policy. Only really worth the commitment against large and rich foes. I'd reckon a collab if you want industry, 90% if you want manpower. I also noticed while reading the hoi4 wiki about puppets, that apparently that the amount of fuel silos or refineries you get is not affected so its the same as if you built those refineries and silos on your own territors, so you get the max amount, but puppets will never give you any dockyards to use. Also I think in the peace deal giving your new puppet their cores is cheaper per province than taking those states for yourself, though that might depend on your ideology. Industry based on 1.9.1 example: if you can use "the prepare collaboration government" operation only 4 times before going to war and annexing 2 fictional countries A&B with the exact same industry: A & B have each in this example 20 military and 20 civilian factories and the operation would give 20% compliance each time They give a significant portion of their industry to you and all the divisions they train are automatically put under your command, as well as giving very good trade deals. In addition, youll get better surrender progress for capitulation. If youre looking for both manpower and building capabilities, learn how to get really good at using this mechanic. I was trying to keep things simple in this analysis since there is a lot of variables that affect the value of doing the mission in particular countries. As Germany it took me 180 days iirc to do it once in France, and 360 the second time. With respect to collaboration governments in general, it means that you don't have to expend resources to pacify the region in general. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Cheers!Join My Discord Community: https://discord.gg/Y9dXkCeMBhMy Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/efficientstrategygamingFind me on Steam: https://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198069212686Paypal Donations: https://www.paypal.com/donate?hosted_button_id=GLAHHX3FNEMEEStreamlabs Donation Page: https://streamlabs.com/efficientstrategygamingBuy Paradox Interactive Games: http://paradoxinteractive.pxf.io/c/1407834/513865/8792Merch Store: https://efficient-strategy-gaming.creator-spring.com So I obviously agree with spreading out collaboration missions and not concentrating them on a few countries. Not sure what else that does. You must log in or register to reply here. so theres no penalty like less factories or less resources available in the conquered country? This is a critical aspect of the warmonger playstyle; if you want to crush your enemies, making quick collaboration governments is critical. If you want a puppet, on the other hand, I'd argue use the peace deal. Because of this I would never release a collaboration government after it is set up by my spies. All you have to do after that is actually take over the country. Not even Czechoslovakia which started at close to 60, got even close. You will want to do this for two reasons: The . I was talking about repeating the prepare collaboration government mission. I do not do that. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America), https://hoi4.paradoxwikis.com/Occupation#Collaboration_government. That said, the benefits are largely situational. Note that if you want 80% compliance in any reasonable timescale you basically need to use the "prepare collaboration government" espionage operation, preferably twice. When you take over the country where you have prepared collaboration, you start out with high compliance in your newly conquered territories. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Paradox Development Studio. All rights reserved. I tried that yesterday and it did not turn into a core unless the game trolled me or I was day dreaming. Collab provide you with 90% of their factories and dockyard. If it has high oil or steel, puppet is better for immediate resources for industrial. and our You are correct. Sorry for the confusion. When doing a warmonger strategy, this is an essential covert operation if you want to do anything with your occupied state. I believe it also cuts down on garrison requirements. Each mission becoming more expensive. I don't tend to try and get full collaboration governments until the game is already decided. In my playthrough, I did it once for Poland and Czech. When comparing two countries, the difference between collaboration percentage correlated closely with difference in percentage of factory use. It's impossible to get compliance above 70% in peace and 77% at war if you are not democratic, in that case you can get it up to 90/97% with local autonomy but democratic countries can't have collaboration governments. On top of this unlike regular puppets they cannot break from from you and increase their autonomy level. Your email address will not be published. I was not even close to getting a single collaboration government, the higher it gets the less you get per tick. If you want manpower or exploit free trade+rich natural resource nation (like china and france) because free trade make your resource only 25%usable, collab (and it still give you 75% of their industry). You get the benefits of running the place, but you dont get quite as much technology from them. You can also do the normal puppet things with a collaboration government like stealing manpower for divisions, etc. If you are, you are, When doing a warmonger strategy, this is an essential covert operation if you want to do. There are a lot of factories in Poland. this helps a lot, thanks! This lets you disarm their military forces while still having the opportunity to spam the compliance mission as much as necessary to get 80% for the collab government afterwards. Collaboration government vs Puppet government. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. What? Collaborative governments are functionally puppets in the game, although unlike most puppets you have full access to their manpower, their resources, and almost all of their factories, making it very important to create them if possible. A Tragedy in 10 PAARts: An Amateur's Italian MP AAR, The Rise and Fall of Hilter's Reich: Dominican Republic MP Latin American Thunderdome Mini-AAR, June 2020 Chain of Command Devs vs Youtubers Clash, I make Youtube guides for EU4, HoI4, and CK3. You will want to do this for two reasons: The collaboration government gives you a larger percentage of local factories and manpower to you, very useful against countries you cannot core but want to exploit the industrial potential of. 3. Press J to jump to the feed. It's in the tier below Reichskommissariat and allows to be cored after reducing autonomy and paying PP. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). how do i increase it? Join the Scoundrel Game Labs Mailing List. Are Collaboration Governments Worth It? Thats really useful, because youll soon be able to use that town yourself! As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. It will take at least 35 days to start and 90 days to complete. It gives huge benefits, its by far the easiest way to raise compliance, and its honestly not a huge expenditure of resources. If I am understanding right, this means there really is no point as a facist country to ever really go down this road then? To reduce this, you must increase your compliance, or your collaboration. All trademarks are property of their respective owners in the US and other countries. Just to add, I am still not sure what all the infilttrate missions. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Seems like a big oversight. Learn what this state means in our, Really quickly, before we begin, you cannot be Democratic. Secret police and Forced Labor will also add, A & B have each in this example 20 military and 20 civilian factories and the operation would give 20% compliance each time, OPTION 1 - 4x on A to set up a collaboration governement and 0x on B, OPTION 2 - 3x Times on A and 1x Times on B, 3 x times the operation on A = 60% compliance and 1 x time on B = 20% compliance, A 60% compliance (0,25+0,65*0,60= 64% of the factories) + Reorganized workforce for A (10% flat Bonus) + B 20% compliance (0,25+0,65*0,2=38%), OPTION 3 -2x Times on A and 2x Times on B, 2 x times the operation on A = 40% compliance and 2 x time on B = 40% compliance, A 40% compliance (0,25+0,65*0,4= 51% of the factories) + Reorganized workfoce for A (10% flat Bonus) + B 40% compliance (0,25+0,65*0,4= 51% of the factories) + Reorganized workfoce for B (10% flat Bonus), Starting from 0 it takes local police force 150 day longer in comparision to reach 20% compliance in comparison to civilian oversight, Half of your compliance % will be added to the resistance target as positive modifier, example: 20% compliance will give you : -10% resistance target, This makes it possible to enable a "less severe" occupation law with the same outcome to have a better daily compliance gain, example: 20% compliance (-10%) + civilian oversight (-10%) = Local Police Force (-20%). It's in the tier below Reichskommissariat and allows to be cored after reducing autonomy and paying PP. A place to share content, ask questions and/or talk about the grand strategy game Hearts of Iron IV by Paradox Development Studio. Collaboration level can turn into additional compliance after a war. Operations all need preparation before they can be launched. For more information, please see our It may not display this or other websites correctly. Can someone explain in simple terms when and when I shouldnt use it? JavaScript is disabled. "The world is a tragedy to those who feel, but a comedy to those that think." Thanks for the answers. Assign spies to the same province in your target country with the mission to Build Intel Network. I'm still not clear on the differences between these. - Horace Walpole, I managed to create German Britain (that's the name for Britain if you take it). Press J to jump to the feed. If not, the problem still persists no? Part 2 of 2 on Spy Agencies 12,710 views Apr 20, 2022 436 Dislike Share Save 71Cloak 18.3K subscribers Explaining and Demonstrating the Cost of building. I usually only look to get to the bonus industry usage as far as collaboration and so I do the mission in 4-5 countries before the war breaks out. The only way to get a collaborational government as a fascist/communist country is to spam the operation 4 times (gives 20% compliance each time, 45% if you are lucky and get an unexpected bonus). New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Strangely in my game the correlation was pretty exact. im just wondering how to get the most out of conquered lands in the new patches, havent played for a year or two now. Yo need to have 80% compliance in the territories of the nation you want to make a collaboration government. It also makes the map neater. There are two stages of collaboration: local collaboration and collaboration governments. You can start it at any time even while at peace. I dont think it is efficient to try install a collaboration government in every country. They also all need some level of network to have been built up in preparation. That depends on how much important resource the area has. FFXIV Castrum Lacus Litore | Final Fantasy 14 Raid Guide, Dirty Rotten Azulmagia Guide FFXIV | Level 50 Blue Mage Quest. They only cost certain amounts of civilian factories for anywhere between 20 days and 3 months, and once you have 3 you will be able to form a collaboration government as soon as you occupy all the enemy land (which should be easier as they capitulate quicker due to lower surrender limit).