When we … This recipe is a homemade version of the notoriously-delicious Carvel ice cream cake - chocolate crunchies and all. Pro tip: make sure the ice cream … A summer birthday doesn't feel complete without an ice cream cake, and this one is incredibly easy to pull off. Let’s dig a little deeper into the center layer of the ice cream cake. First, Carvel smashes up the cookies for the ice cream cake. Press the Oreo butter mixture into a 13×9 inch baking dish. Super yummy but made with low-quality ingredients. The key to making an ice cream cake … An old-school Carvel ice cream cake is usually two different flavors of soft-serve ice cream, separated by a middle layer of cookie crumbles and chocolate sauce. Next, spread the softened cookies ‘n cream ice cream overtop of the crushed Oreos and then place in the freezer for 2-3 hours or until firm. Aug 19, 2012 - Every year growing up I had a Carvel Ice Cream cake for my birthday. The 2/3 cup crushed Oreos will be reserved for the top of the ice cream cake. Just a few irresistible ingredients are all it takes to make your favorite Carvel Ice Cream Cakes pop. And there you have it. How It Works. The month of August was great because my brother had an ice cream cake two weeks after for his birthday too.