These tomatoes … This is an heirloom variety, and much like a “Roma” style tomato. Amish Paste tomatoes are an acorn-shaped, deep-red, paste-type fruit. We use our canned tomato sauce in so many recipes during the long winter months, from homemade pasta dishes, homemade pizzas, chili, and more. Use a paste tomato such as Amish Paste or San Marzano. This Amish heirloom has thick flesh and few seeds. These tomatoes are recognized for the succulent taste and their thick, juicy texture. The flavors will be dense, intense and interesting. The vines produce medium-sized, 8 to 12 ounce fruit. It performs better when … Amish Paste … Amish Paste is an heirloom tomato variety. If I play my cards right, I can grow enough paste tomatoes (I love Amish Paste and San Marzano the most) in my raised bed garden to keep us stocked in tomato … Amish Paste – Our absolute Go-To tomato when it comes to canning salsa and sauce! Thick walled andm eaty, this is a perfect tomato for canners. Great answer for winter! Make the recipe using both dried peppers and rehydrated dried tomatoes. Amish Paste tomatoes come from Pennsylvanian Amish communities.