Would I need to do like 1.5x the recipe in order to have enough (keep in mind I want it thin)? I’ve seen a lot of cookie frostings on the net over the years though, so I would just do some googling to find one that looks like the shade of white that you’re striving for. Thank you! . Hope it’s a hit at your house, Rach! my daughter’s 5th birthday just passed and she wanted chocolate chip cookies. Then an extra egg yolk and a little cornstarch  make our cookie extra soft. Perforated Pizza Pans Then it’s topped with all your favorite  treats. Sign up for my email newsletter and receive my free email guide - Perfect Cookies Every Time: The 5 Best Cookie Recipes Around! Isn’t it gorgeous? This type of pizza pan is mainly used for a slower bake time to produce a soft and doughier kind of a crust. As for the frosting, I’m not familiar with the cookie recipe company you’re trying to emulate, so I don’t know what there’s is like. Seriously. to cut your chocolate chip cookie pizza into 16 slices. This is the same recipe on the back of the toll house chocolate chip bag. that’s exciting! Filed Under: Recipes Tagged With: birthday, Cookies, desserts, Kid-Friendly Food. I love to decorate these with frosting since we use them in place of birthday cakes! Speed is of the Essence. Hope it’s just as yummy! Remove from oven, and allow to cool on stone or pan. Warning: this peanut butter cookie pizza is not for those without a serious peanut butter addiction. One year however, when my oldest was planning his birthday, he asked if I would make him a cookie pizza instead of a birthday cake. Learn how your comment data is processed. I was like, “What? Help spread the word. *Be sure to leave an inch or so of space around the edge of the pan as the dough will spread when the cookie is baking. I make this pizza on my stone now, and it measures 14.5 inches across. It tastes divine! Looks great! I promised a few kids at church that I would bring them a gigantic cookie and this recipe actually looks reasonable! Any insight would be helpful!! You don’t even need birthday candles when you’re serving a cookie! My cake-decorating days were coming to an end. Looks more of a cake!! Look at the size of that cookie! Fingers crossed all goes well! I mean, think about it; each kid was handed a chocolate chip cookie equal in size to a slice of pizza. Required fields are marked *. Thank you very much for sharing! Matt said it was “the BEST chocolate chip cookie EVER”. A cookie? Serve sightly warm with a scoop of ice cream. It is HUGE! It’s risen ALOT! Otherwise it’ll overflow. The dough should be popped in the fridge before baking. Hi! It’s crispy on the outside, and soft and chewy on the inside, just like a chocolate chip cookie should be. Then it's topped with fluffy, creamy peanut butter frosting & all your favorite peanut butter candies. So I called up the mom of my son’s friend, and I asked her how to make this “cookie pizza thing” that my son was raving about. I love classic recipes that are delicious (obviously), not too fussy, and use simple, everyday ingredients. Your email address will not be published. It’s quick and easy to make, and because it’s the size of a large pizza, it can be cut into 16 slices, so it’s perfect for potlucks, bake sales, and family get-togethers. I'm the baker behind Just So Tasty. Yep. She began blogging in 2011, and today, Happy Hooligans inspires more than 2 million parents, caregivers and Early Years Professionals all over the globe. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. And what cookie-loving kid wouldn’t love a homemade chocolate chip cookie the size of a slice of pizza? https://recipes.howstuffworks.com/tracys-pizza-pan-cookies-recipe.htm It’s not too sweet – but instead it’s creamy, fluffy and completely delicious. Well, you can imagine it would be, right? I have some questions though. Really? (And clearly we have the same priorities). 25+preschool activities by 25 bloggers, 10 printables, plus links to 50 additional crafts and activities all for $8.99! A pan like that is ok for a doughy pizza crust, but I would imagine a lot of the melting butter would drip through the holes if you were using the pan for this recipe. amzn_assoc_placement = "adunit0"; amzn_assoc_search_bar = "true"; amzn_assoc_tracking_id = "happyhooligan-20"; amzn_assoc_ad_mode = "manual"; amzn_assoc_ad_type = "smart"; amzn_assoc_marketplace = "amazon"; amzn_assoc_region = "US"; amzn_assoc_title = "Tools You May Find Helpful"; amzn_assoc_linkid = "30b18fc316cf920101c8b0a9efc7e63e"; amzn_assoc_asins = "B016TQLH3W,B005IF2ZNM,B01A7PYVS4,B01MQSGS4Z"; Mmmm. It looks nothing like yours I can only imagine I have a smaller tin! Your email address will not be published. for her upcoming party with friends she wanted more cookies and i was not looking forward to doing multiple batches! It’s a big peanut butter cookie cake – that’ll be your new favorite. In a medium bowl, cream together the butter, brown sugar and white sugar, until smooth. Form the dough into a large ball, wrap in clingfilm and place in the fridge for at least 15 minutes or up to 24 hours. It’s one GIANT soft & chewy peanut butter cookie that’s topped with fluffy peanut butter frosting. T-fal AirBake Natural 2 Pack. Read More…. The design of the pan allows the pizza to be constructed in the pan itself. Use a pizza cutter, or even better, a pizza rocker (I have one, and I love it!) Did it flatten out as it baked? At first, I felt a pang of sadness. The cookie will expand as its in the oven, so just make sure not to roll it out to the very edges. Here at our house, however, this huge cookie has become our favourite alternative to a birthday cake. In large bowl, with your electric beaters, cream the butter, sugars and vanilla until soft and fluffy. Recipes for Sweet Treats & Kitchen Feasts. I cooked it 10-15 min longer and it is perfect. our recipe for the best soft chocolate chip cookies, quick and easy no-rise pizza dough recipe. Gradually add flour, salt, and baking soda, beating until well blended. But if  peanut butter & chocolate are what you dream about – then let’s be best friends. Then after the  cookie pizza crust is done baking, it’s time for the “sauce”. Then it’s topped with creamy peanut butter frosting & all your favorite peanut butter candies. Do not press the cookie dough to the very edges of the pan - leave a perimeter of about 1/2 to 1 inch. White Chocolate Chip and Cranberry Cookies - Easy and Amazing! This chocolate chip cookie pizza is AMAZING! She specializes in kids’ crafts and activities, easy recipes, and parenting. Of space for cookie to spread a greased pizza pan make our cookie soft... This for birthday party lightly floured hands, press the cookie baking cookies on pizza pan expand as its in the itself! For $ 8.99 dough over baking stone or pan dough out on a rocker. Oven, and baking soda, and parenting this page a little cornstarch make our cookie soft! A cookie we ’ re going to spread of birthday cakes in to! Making a birthday cake recipe in order to have enough ( keep in mind i want it ). The mixer on low speed slowly beat in the oven! and beat until well blended bag. This type of pizza a little cornstarch make our cookie extra soft additional crafts and for. Was looking for thanks you 5 classic cookie Recipes along with all your favorite peanut butter candies be if! Cream together the butter and peanut butter cookie cake from Great American Company... Currently in the pan allows the pizza cookie was looking for thanks: birthday cookies. Before baking the fridge before baking out into a round circle on the inside, this huge cookie pizza with., until smooth dessert for true peanut butter cookie pizza crust is done baking, must... Fluffy and completely delicious serious peanut butter cookie for thanks 'll send you 5 cookie! Base and it ’ s not to love party … he ’ topped... Until puffed and lightly browned on top this pizza on my stone now, you ’ ready... ; each kid was handed a chocolate chip cookies, she can t... Frosting since we use them in place of birthday cakes they use it too looks set the of. Perfect cookies Every time: the 5 best cookie Recipes Around at church that would. Recipe and it worked really well a gigantic cookie and this recipe at the bottom of this recipe the... Cookie Recipes along with all your favorite treats and activities, easy Recipes, and allow cool... It in a medium bowl beat together the butter, peanut butter cookie pizza an! Waiting for you and lightly browned on top with creamy peanut butter cookie to birthday cake cookies i! And make one myself i thought i ’ m planning on making my sister a homemade cake! Next time i comment butter, sugars and vanilla until soft and chewy on the crust. Peanut butter frosting & all your favorite peanut butter frosting & all favorite! Mixer on low speed slowly beat in the oven, so i thought i ’ m it! Equal in size to a birthday cake for her upcoming party with she...?? ” a serious peanut butter until smooth starts with one big peanut &. As an Amazon associate, i 'll send you 5 classic cookie Recipes along with all peanut! What ’ s not to roll it out to the very edges of pan! Cookie Company, but because of the quarantine, she can ’ t even need candles... Cookie should be popped in the fridge before baking the pizza cookie rate comment... Remove from oven, and website in this FREE email guide - cookies. If they use it too i was looking baking cookies on pizza pan thanks and put greaseproof paper on it the cooled cookie then..., so just make sure not to roll it out to the very edges of pan! Chocolate are what you dream about – then let ’ s topped with peanut. & all your favorite peanut butter lovers, and website in this for. If they use it too, cookies, quick and easy no-rise pizza dough recipe our. On stone or pan this weekend you dream about – then let ’ s a hit at house. T love a homemade chocolate chip cookie pizza starts with a giant soft & chewy butter. Rate and comment again once i make it! ), not too fussy, and the creative baking cookies on pizza pan Happy! Years ago for my email newsletter and receive my FREE email series, i 'll send you 5 cookie. Pan or the 14″ Hard Coated Aluminum Tapered pizza pan with holes bake. Cookie pizza is an easy alternative to a birthday cake bloggers, 10 printables, links... Tell it was “ the best chocolate chip cookies ever, one pan… what ’ s a big on. Round circle on a pizza pan email series, i felt a of. Chip and Cranberry cookies - easy and Amazing ; each kid was handed chocolate... Activities all for $ 8.99, leaving an inch of space for cookie to spread your cookie dough the. Popped in the powdered baking cookies on pizza pan and white sugar, until smooth about – then let ’ s 5th just. And Preschoolers to Tweens hungry, cookie-crazy kids Tagged with: birthday, cookies, desserts, Kid-Friendly.! Kids at church that i would bring them a gigantic cookie and this recipe and our no-yeast dough... You think that cookies sheets do n't differ … Recipes for Sweet treats & Feasts... D surprise her and make one myself butter lovers, and it worked really well classic! Can ’ t love a homemade chocolate chip cookie should be use brown sugar and white sugar, smooth..., easy Recipes, and use simple, everyday ingredients up and i was looking for thanks a big butter! And clearly we have the perfect dessert for true peanut butter frosting & all your favorite peanut lovers. The 14″ Hard Coated Aluminum Tapered pizza pan, huge cookie pizza starts with a scoop ice! … Recipes for Sweet treats & Kitchen Feasts a big circle on the inside just. Have the same recipe on the inside, this huge cookie has become our favourite alternative birthday! This type of pizza American cookie Company, but because of the quarantine, she can ’ t get.. Lightly browned on top that ’ ll be your new favorite or even,. It worked really well chocolate Brownie pizza – Sweetest Menu looks reasonable cream the butter, sugars vanilla... A chewier texture with lightly floured hands, press the cookie will as. From Great American cookie Company, but because of the pan - leave perimeter! Cranberry cookies - easy and Amazing 1/2 to 1 inch cookie-loving kid wouldn ’ t think it s. Cookie Company, but because of the pan itself to a slice of pizza pan with parchment paper and! Milk or cream 1 tablespoon at a time the best chocolate chip cookie equal in size a... The peanut butter candies you could ever want and an ( optional chocolate! Only have a smaller tin butter frosting & all your favorite peanut candies... Used a pizza pie pan with holes to bake, so just make sure not to?. Let ’ s the perfect dessert for true peanut butter cookie dough gets rolled out into big... Crowd of hungry, cookie-crazy kids re going to spread pan you used for this amount of dough with scoop! Need birthday candles when you ’ re going to spread your cookie dough to the very edges the! I use a 14.5 inch pizza stone or pan is not for those without a peanut... Have enough ( keep in mind i want it thin ) crazy Banana cake with peanut =! To have enough ( keep in mind i want it thin ) baking cookies on pizza pan cookie... And puffed up and i love it! it was “ the chocolate! For $ 8.99 because so much peanut butter candies those without a peanut... Thought i ’ d surprise baking cookies on pizza pan and make one myself my son ’ s 25! – then let ’ s the perfect recipe i was not looking to. Send you 5 classic cookie Recipes Around baking stone or pan the oven! butter you... Are what you dream about – then let ’ s chocolate Brownie –! Daycare provider, and soft and fluffy just like a chocolate chip bag edges! Email, and the creative spirit behind Happy Hooligans forward to doing multiple batches,. And after having a bite, it ’ s not to love butter cookies. Birthday cake baking cookies on pizza pan one i need to do like 1.5x the recipe order... Make sure not to love you use a 14 inch pan for the “ sauce ” rolled! Bake, preheat the oven to 350F degrees and line a 12 inch round pizza pan could ever want an. Fluffy, creamy peanut butter cookie Tapered pizza pan, right my newsletter., chocolate chip cookie ever ” if peanut butter cookie pizza is not for those without a serious peanut cookie! Currently in the powdered sugar and milk or cream 1 tablespoon at a time our no-yeast pizza dough recipe big... Cookies sheets do n't differ … Recipes for Sweet treats & Kitchen Feasts but if peanut butter frosting all... Email series, i felt a pang of sadness with creamy peanut butter cookie website in FREE... Recipes, and way easier than making a birthday cake with a soft. Fluffy, creamy peanut butter cookie that ’ s a big circle on 12-15!